Recent Posts1
General Discussion / Re: Movie Review: Civil War - by Forward Observer
« Last post by Jackalope on Today at 09:44:12 AM » My wife and I were finally able to seeCivil War yesterday. We both found the first half of the movie to be somewhat slow and plodding. The action picked up during the last forty five minutes, and there was a crescendo at the end. As has been noted, there's no indication as to which side we should be rooting for. However, there are clear depictions of evil, and the raw depravity of war. If you look beyond the purely entertainment value, you will find some excellent lessons.
One of the takeaways from the film is how chaotic an American Civil War would be. There's one scene in the film where folks are pinned down by a sniper. We never find out why the sniper was shooting everyone. The iconic scene where a soldier (essentially someone in a uniform, could be a militia man, or just someone who likes camo clothing) asks, "What kind of American are you?", again reinforces the chaotic situation. Essentially, this person becomes judge, jury, and executioner. I would imagine that old grudges would be settled, and petty crime would be dealt with severely. The film generates lots of questions and thought experiments. Would law enforcement exist in such a scenario? How about the justice system? If you catch looters, how do you deal with them? (IMHO, there's not much worse than a thief). How do people get food? How do you differentiate between opposing forces?
The film also depicts, probably accidentally, the need to be armed. Another lesson was don't be a refugee. Travel during war time is hazardous to your health. Also, stay out of cities, but rural environments can be just as dangerous. I'd suggest hunkering down, and staying within your own immediate AO, but that wouldn't make a good movie.
The line, "What kind of American are you?", resonates within me, but for different reasons than in the movie. Today, we see "Americans" shouting "Death to America", as they protest whatever is the "cause du jour". American culture has drifted from the original intent of our founding fathers, as the government implements more freedom limiting laws. We were once the great melting pot; now we're a fractured society. We've lost the pride in our country, and patriotism is frowned upon by the media and academia. Could the U.S. devolve into what was depicted in the movie? I say, "Yes!", and it may be unavoidable.
So, was it a good movie? If you were looking for an action movie or a popcorn thriller, then the answer would be no. If you're looking to observe one possible future scenario, then the answer would be yes. The movie was mildly entertaining, but it also served as an excellent means of projecting possible threats and possibilities. If you look beyond the purely entertainment value, you will find some valuable lessons. Whether the movie is mediocre or good is, of course, subjective, but I suggest watching the film with an open mind. For me, I rate it four out of five stars.
One of the takeaways from the film is how chaotic an American Civil War would be. There's one scene in the film where folks are pinned down by a sniper. We never find out why the sniper was shooting everyone. The iconic scene where a soldier (essentially someone in a uniform, could be a militia man, or just someone who likes camo clothing) asks, "What kind of American are you?", again reinforces the chaotic situation. Essentially, this person becomes judge, jury, and executioner. I would imagine that old grudges would be settled, and petty crime would be dealt with severely. The film generates lots of questions and thought experiments. Would law enforcement exist in such a scenario? How about the justice system? If you catch looters, how do you deal with them? (IMHO, there's not much worse than a thief). How do people get food? How do you differentiate between opposing forces?
The film also depicts, probably accidentally, the need to be armed. Another lesson was don't be a refugee. Travel during war time is hazardous to your health. Also, stay out of cities, but rural environments can be just as dangerous. I'd suggest hunkering down, and staying within your own immediate AO, but that wouldn't make a good movie.
The line, "What kind of American are you?", resonates within me, but for different reasons than in the movie. Today, we see "Americans" shouting "Death to America", as they protest whatever is the "cause du jour". American culture has drifted from the original intent of our founding fathers, as the government implements more freedom limiting laws. We were once the great melting pot; now we're a fractured society. We've lost the pride in our country, and patriotism is frowned upon by the media and academia. Could the U.S. devolve into what was depicted in the movie? I say, "Yes!", and it may be unavoidable.
So, was it a good movie? If you were looking for an action movie or a popcorn thriller, then the answer would be no. If you're looking to observe one possible future scenario, then the answer would be yes. The movie was mildly entertaining, but it also served as an excellent means of projecting possible threats and possibilities. If you look beyond the purely entertainment value, you will find some valuable lessons. Whether the movie is mediocre or good is, of course, subjective, but I suggest watching the film with an open mind. For me, I rate it four out of five stars.
