Ya know I used to get wrapped around the axles about MOA and chasing that extra .5 but I found out something. Time is sensitive when you're in a gunfight. All the fun time I've spent overseas taught me another thing - the guy who normally hits first wins. I have yet to see anyone that got hit in the torso (ESAPIs included) not be out of the fight at least temporarily and that time costs you fire and maneuver.
Target detection is a skill in and upon itself. It takes trained eyes to pick up targets. Have you ever gone out in the woods with one of those old Fudds that hunts religiously every year and can spot that damn turkey or deer in clutter a couple of hundred yards off even when it ain't moving? That's a trained eye. The human eye will naturally be drawn to movement but it takes getting out in the brush and actually learning the patterns of your AO to be able to pickup stuff that ain't supposed to be there especially when it ain't moving. And when I state MoM I mean a torso sized target presented at full frontal aspect. That cat in the prone is bad news for you especially if your moving. I had a sniper hit me with a rock at about 10 feet when I was taking a piss in the field one time - really I didn't see him at all. So spotting a joe that just lays down in some brush or light cover? Probably 25 meters if your lucky and he's being real still. By then he's more than got ya. You won't find a lot of folks that can do 4 MoA off the street but with some hands on it's not unrealistic.
I would expect any decent semi to be capable of at least 3 MoA and an COTS bolt gun at 1.5. I'll tell ya right now - avoid getting hung up on the "My rifle can do 1.5 MoA all day long" - it's a gay ass argument suited for arfcom. Riflewise? Not as important as the shooter and his known ability to get lead on target using his rifle and ammo combo in a timely fashion. Remember the marksmanship triad - shooter, rifle, ammo in that order.
Ken, think about this. That M193 with the sights on an AR15A2 20" zeroed at 3.2" high at 100 yards is going to cross it's ballistic plane on the far end at 250 yards. So if you aim center mass at a target within 300 yards you're going to hit it. But you have to run the numbers based on your rifle and round combo. The numbers I put up were for 3 common rifles - an AR15A2 with 20" barrel using M193, A Metric FAL (my personal fav) with a 21" barrel using M80, and a standard run of the mill Romy AK with a 16" barrel running Wolf. Whatever your running YMMV.
BTW - I did screw up my numbers for the FAL. 100 Yards should be 3.43". I was looking at the wrong round column on my pad.