Yes & No JoJo. You bring up a valid point ala - Normalcy Bias. Let me tell our story.
Late October 2012 the Cat. 1 Hurricane Sandy hit the tri-state metro area of NJ, NY, and CT. MrsMac and I knew that once it hit a 8' surge over high tide during a new moon was coming our way in RI.
The local fire department asked us to evacuate however they would not allow us to take our two cats to the facility. After a short discussion we decided to stay.
I put up our storm boards thinking they would prevent the egress of the ocean into our home but alas they didn't. The surge arrived at about 1900 hrs and the surge water started to seep into our home when all of a sudden our house rose.
To make a long story short, our house rose from its 100 year old stilts and when the water ran out (Flooded) the house came down with a resounding thump.
We ended up with about a 18-24" flood in the house and most of the 100+ year joists snapped when the house came down.
As the water started to seem in, I turned off the master switch to the electrical panel. Lit an Aladdin lamp, grabbed the Grundig radio and some bottles of water and went upstairs with MrsMac and our two cats.
So why did we stay you might ask...Well first and foremost the chances of the surge hitting us was only 50/50. Then the evacuation center offered to us would not accept our two cats - My wife's children. Last, I was not really worried if even we did get flooded as the wind from the hurricane was well west of us.
In all, there was ~$100K worth of damage. We had FEMA Flood Insurance which initially only agreed to pay ~$50K in damages however through my persistence and the help of our US Congressman, they paid ~$90K with the other $10K coming from our retirement.
So there you go about MrsMac and my normalcy bias.
Now on another subject that few are talking about. Why do people live in high probability locations that would cause the loss of life and property? Why do insurance companies insure folks for high risk locations? Why does the government (FEMA) insure properties in high flooding probability locations? We are all paying for it.
And then there is: Why has California stopped "control burns" about ten years ago?