no, this is not a new topic. but I feel that (correct me if I'm wrong here) alot of emphasis has been placed on improvised fishing poles, but very little is placed on store-bought poles.
of course, you can catch a fish just as well with an improvised pole as you could with a modern store-bought rod & reel, but why not take advantage of our modern society while it's still around?
I just bought a new pole a few days ago which is what made me think of this.
since I've been a prepper, I've always just carried a fishing kit in my BOB, but never thought about including the pole itself because I just assumed that it'd be too cumbersome and awkward to have a pole snagging on every branch and bush that I hike past. but honestly, if you get the right size pole, and break it in half and tape it together, it really isn't so awkward. you may add an extra pound to your kit at the most, and an unlimited food source is a pretty damn good trade-off for an extra pound and about $30 IMHO. and like I said before, of course you can catch fish with an improvised pole, but a real fishing pole just makes it that much easier, and the more stress I can remove from my bug-out experience, the better.
one thing to consider is that an improvised pole is really only good for float fishing. well let's say that whatever species of fish that are most common in your AO are more likely to bite at a lure that is being reeled in? sure, you can probably still snag a few with a stagnant float, but wouldn't you rather snag a few dozen by doing it the more effective way?
just a thought... just like the majority of my threads, the topic is open for discussion. I just wanted to share my current thought process.