Umm..........It's not a debate issue. I'm not looking at the rifle as a primary or even really a defense weapon. It's strictly a want. If I were interested in caliber I'd put away for a .50. I just happen to really like the look, feel, action, trigger, etc. of that particular Savage rifle. It's a great price for a bolt action .338 compared to other vendors also. Plus, I already have rifles chambered for .308 and 7.62x54r.