Well let me give you some biblical teachings, just to let you know I am Catholic so I'm supposed to be anti-gay well fuck that, anyway here goes, just to let you know I don't where to look you might have to look it up, anyway the bible says to love your neighbor, never judge a person and the most important thing its GODS job to judge humans not humans.. Just thought that might help you get rid of your ignorance and holier than though bullshit.
I don't want to seem rude Alex, but that's not proper theology. That "tolerance" philosophy comes from pluralism which have been trying to subvert the church for decades. In John 8 we see Christ speaking to the woman whose life he clearly saved and he tells her he is not condemning (aka judging) her, but "go and leave your life of sin." Saying that now is considered intolerance, hateful, and right wing fanaticism. Post modernism doesn't acknowledge the difference between admonishment and judging. They are two very separate things.
Here are some further verses for consideration.
http://www.openbible.info/topics/correcting_a_brother I do want to note I don't take a tough stance on non-believers regarding this topic and it's not appropriate to approach them regarding this without preaching the gospel first. That should be understood for obvious reasons. That said, when you say "God is the judge" keep in mind that the sin of omission is a real one. I hope this helps, but if you don't accept this please understand your argument ceases with me and begins with the Word.