Unchained Preppers

General Category => Gear Review => Topic started by: JohnyMac on March 19, 2021, 03:07:41 PM

Title: The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever
Post by: JohnyMac on March 19, 2021, 03:07:41 PM
The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever

(http://navigatorbiz.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/log-sawed-3_19_2021-v2.png)

Every year or so, I take time to inventory what I carry in my 'get home bag'. This year I am trying to get my pack from a winter weight of 40-lbs (30-lbs summer weight) to under 30-lbs (25-lbs summer weight). The difference in weights between winter and summer revolves around clothes. During this year's inventory review, I will also analyze the items I am packing to see if they make sense. 

I currently pack a nifty folding handsaw made by Felco 60 that weighs in at 5-ounces. The saw with its 6-inch blade has done an adequate job on small stuff; However, I have been looking for years for a bigger option that did not weight a ton. Well I found it and it is called Boreal21 by Agawa (https://agawagear.com/products/custom-boreal21-kit).

(http://navigatorbiz.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/felco-saw-3_19_2021-v2.png)

The blade on the Boreal21 is 21-inches long and weighs in complete, with pouch and extra blade at 24-ounces. The saw comes in 15 & 24-inches too. You can buy the saw alone for around $75- but I went the complete package route. The saw is available in two colors - Green/black or yellow/black grips. I went with yellow because it is easier to spot when I lay it down in the woods. Last, I ordered it with the Sidney Rancher Aggressive blades not the other options available. The all-purpose blade and hunter blade used for sawing through bones.

(http://navigatorbiz.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/saw-review-3_19_2021-v2.png)

Now for the proof in the pudding. I went out and tried it out on a 6-inch tree that had come down in the winter. It took me ~4-minutes to cut through the tree trunk (see feature article image).

The collapsed size is 21 1/2 x 1 1/8 x 7/8-inches (L x H X W). When collapsed no blade is exposed so you could easily find a spot inside or outside along your pack. I will probably leave the pouch at home as not being needed.

(http://navigatorbiz.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/closed-saw-3_19_2021-v3.png)

Total cost for the saw, scabbard, and extra blade was $110- and in my opinion well worth the cost.

My only negative at this point is the weight. Although 19-ounces is not bad for a backpacking saw, a sub 16-ounce saw  would be better. Probably cost prohibitive to the average buyer though. 

In closing, I highly recommend this saw and it will see a lot of use on the trail and around the redoubt.

(http://navigatorbiz.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/liberty-tree-12_27_2020-V7-Thumbnail.png)
Title: Re: The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever
Post by: grizz on March 19, 2021, 03:15:56 PM
I got a Silky last year and only used it a few times but really like it
Title: Re: The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever
Post by: Jackalope on March 19, 2021, 04:29:31 PM
I guess my question is what is the reasoning for carrying a saw and the added weight?  Why not a hatchet?  Or, why either a saw or a hatchet?  I guess if you see a need in a post-apocalyptic scenario, then a metal cutting blade would be a good idea too.

I did, at one time, carry a saw.  However, in the past 40 years or so, I can't recall one time when a saw was absolutely needed.  I also use to carry a small Marbles safety hatchet.  Again, it was never used, so it was removed from the pack.  I do carry a Victorinox Multitool which has a short saw blade, which I have used a few times, but it's an EDC item.
Title: Re: The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever
Post by: RB in GA on March 19, 2021, 04:40:13 PM
I've tried several of the small folding saws like your Felco- Silky's are by far the best ones I've found for ease of use. I have a Gomboy and it's really, really easy to process wood for fires, etc... 
The Boreal you mentioned has several good reviews and is mentioned a good bit on various bushcraft sites- it's just too expensive for me to justify buying when my Silky does what I need.
But I do think everyone should have a good saw in their get home bag. If you can afford it, this looks like a good option.
As to why a saw over an axe? A saw is safer. You'd be suprised how many people dont use an axe properly and end up in an ER. In a go-to-hell situation, I'd rather not be putting a CAT on somebody that used one wrong. 
Title: Re: The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever
Post by: grizz on March 19, 2021, 05:56:06 PM
Hatchet and knife for splitting and battoning, Saw for cutting cuz its easier than chopping
Title: Re: The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever
Post by: Nemo on March 19, 2021, 06:44:55 PM
I keep one of the folding saws below real handy.  It worked well on everything so far.

Nemo

https://www.gerbergear.com/en-us/shop/cutting-tools/saws/exchange-a-blade-46036 (https://www.gerbergear.com/en-us/shop/cutting-tools/saws/exchange-a-blade-46036)
Title: Re: The Best Backpacking Wood Saw Ever
Post by: grizz on March 19, 2021, 07:32:51 PM
I keep one of the folding saws below real handy.  It worked well on everything so far.

Nemo

https://www.gerbergear.com/en-us/shop/cutting-tools/saws/exchange-a-blade-46036 (https://www.gerbergear.com/en-us/shop/cutting-tools/saws/exchange-a-blade-46036)

I had that gerber for years and replaced with the Silky after I broke it.